Give the Scorched Holy Symbol to the Masked Orphan Matron.
This large jack-o'-lantern rests in the middle of the village. It eyes those who look upon it, betraying a dark menace within.
Smashing the pumpking reveals an old, scorched holy symbol.
You found this inside the Headless Horseman's jack-o-lantern? It is an old symbol of the Light. If must have been the Horseman's, before he was cursed and turned into the monster he is today. Thank you, <name>. This symbol deserves to be with paladins. I will make sure they get it.
Oh, and I almost forgot! You have a secret admirer...
One of the children wanted you to have this. She was too shy to give it to you herself.